Ironic-Design

Ironic in OpenKeel: design note

Status: decided and deployed on a test cluster (2026-10-31): Kolla images, Redfish virtual media, flat and noop, json-rpc, sushy-tools on a new kind cluster. Ironic stays upstream Python at OpenStack 2026.2 (user decision); openkeel-ironic is a Helm chart around it, not a Go rewrite. Evidence below was measured on this host on 2026-10-31.

Decision 1: image source

**Decision: Kolla, debian-trixie, pinned by digest, with binaries run directly** (no kolla_start, no sudo), plus a standard unprivileged nginx image for the conductor's HTTP server. Metal3 solves a standalone, Keystone-less use case and would run only under emulation here.

Consequences for okadm: it assumes <imageRepository>/openkeel-<project>:<imageTag> (internal/deploy/values.go:78) and an image per architecture is new. The manifest gets an external image declaration per architecture for this component, and okadm selects it from the node architecture, as it does for the base image.

Decision 2: first boot mode

Redfish virtual media first (redfish-virtual-media): no DHCP or TFTP in the cluster, only conductor to BMC and node to conductor HTTP. iPXE and DHCP come next (ipxe, dnsmasq sidecar with NET_ADMIN, NET_RAW, Multus attachment).

Limits of virtual media:

• the BMC must implement Redfish VirtualMedia InsertMedia by URL (on some vendors this needs a licence) and must reach the conductor's HTTP server;
• the IPA ramdisk still needs an IP address: DHCP from the physical network, or a static network_data on the node (DHCP-less boot, not tested here). It must then reach the Ironic API and the conductor's HTTP server;
• UEFI ISOs need an ESP image ([conductor]/bootloader) or a prebuilt deploy_iso.

QCOW2 images: the server never boots the QCOW2 itself. It boots the IPA ISO, IPA writes the image to the local disk, then the server reboots from disk. With the defaults (force_raw_images, [agent]/stream_raw_images, [agent]/image_download_source = http) the conductor converts a Glance image to raw with qemu-img in its cache, so the PVC must hold the raw size. An image given by URL goes directly to IPA, which converts it in the ramdisk's memory, unless image_download_source = local. The image must be a whole-disk image with a bootloader matching the server's architecture and firmware. Go Glance serves the original QCOW2 only with glance_store.csi.keep_original (default true); otherwise, and for images made by Cinder upload-to-image, it serves raw while disk_format may say otherwise (to test).

Decision 3: network interface

The brief recommends flat. The code adds a constraint: flat is a Neutron interface. ironic/drivers/modules/network/flat.py requires [neutron]/cleaning_network in validate and raises NetworkError when no port has a VIF to bind, so a deployment without Nova or Neutron VIFs fails. noop needs no Neutron.

**Decision: enable flat and noop, default flat,** with noop on standalone nodes (tests, operator-driven deployments). neutron and ironic-networking come later.

Decision 4: RPC

json-rpc (conductor port 8089, per-pod DNS name from the StatefulSet's headless Service, Keystone auth): no RabbitMQ user for a component that needs it for nothing else. Notifications stay off.

Decision 5: networks and test hardware

To be supplied by the user for real hardware: provisioning network (VLAN, IP range, who runs DHCP), BMC network, one Redfish machine. Without them, tests use sushy-tools in a test-only image on a new kind cluster.

What sushy-tools on kind can prove: chart, okadm, Keystone, openstack baremetal, Redfish power and boot-device calls, enroll to available with automated cleaning off. What it cannot prove: a real deployment. Kind nodes have no KVM and the ramdisk would not boot, so IPA, virtual media boot, image writing and active stay unverified.

Facts that shape the chart

• System scope. Ironic's baremetal:node:create needs system_scope:all, but baremetal:node:create:self_owned_node lets a project-scoped admin or service create nodes its project owns. Measured through Go Keystone: a system-scoped admin (--os-system-scope all) sees and manages everything; a project-scoped admin creates its own nodes, does not see others', and cannot list conductors.
• API server. ironic-api binds in each worker (Address already in use with api_workers: 2): one worker per pod, scaled by replicas.
• HTTP server. httpboot/agent_images holds absolute symlinks into images/: nginx mounts the whole volume at the conductor's path, or cached images answer 404.
• Service user. openkeel-keystone bootstrap.services.ironic (user ironic, role service, catalog type baremetal, port 6385). openkeel-chart adds a database-url key in SQLAlchemy form next to the Go database-dsn. PyMySQL connects without TLS: same network trust as the lab, to review for production.
• Optional component. okadm deploys it only with --components ironic; the role provisioning is checked by okadm plan.

Verification (kind cluster ok-ironic, arm64, openkeel-ironic/test/smoke.sh)

| okadm install --components ironic in lab mode (kind, 3 nodes) and in production mode (3 API, 2 conductors, Galera 3), then smoke.sh on each, on 2026-11-02 | production on kind needed two test-only additions: the lab's DNS NetworkPolicy workaround (kindnet drops DNS replies to pods selected by ingress policies; Keystone fails the same way) and automated_clean: false (no ramdisk) |

Production gaps seen on 2026-11-02: okadm checks the provisioning role label (warning only) but no chart receives global.nodeRoles, so conductors are not pinned to provisioning nodes (one ran on an unlabelled node). Two conductors with required anti-affinity need two schedulable nodes, while okadm plan asks for one provisioning node.

Not verified: a real machine or IPA, active, flat with Neutron, Glance as image source, Nova's driver against this chart, amd64 digests (rendered, never run), networkPolicy.bmcCIDRs (rendered only), automated cleaning, okadm upgrade.

Known gaps, to report rather than hide